Autofocus 2.0 - compiled improvements here
Original Post
Hi,
let's start to collect here best practices & improvements for AF system.
We can list what to change and also what NOT to change.
From my subjective experience:
-ONE list is good practise (several lists causes distraction/overhead)
-all kind of items can be added (concrete actions as well as vague projects)
Other comments?
let's start to collect here best practices & improvements for AF system.
We can list what to change and also what NOT to change.
From my subjective experience:
-ONE list is good practise (several lists causes distraction/overhead)
-all kind of items can be added (concrete actions as well as vague projects)
Other comments?
Reply by Mike
Good start!
- Simpler is better and,
- Learn the system on paper before running to a software solution.
- Simpler is better and,
- Learn the system on paper before running to a software solution.
Reply by Dean
Yes - one list approach is good since i think one reason for procrastination & overwhelm is complex setup and maintenance...
Reply by Michel
I like the idea of "all kind of items". I got frustrated with GTD since the processing stuff to actions is barrier. I know that goals needs to broken into actions, but doing separately that kind of processing is hmmm ... complex.
Reply by Dixie
How you guys (and girls) dismiss something? I have several items that i need to do someday in future but currently i can't get them forward (depends on other things & people)
Reply by Mikko
My experience & recommendations so far
-keep it simple (one big list)
-pen & paper approach, easy to jot down
-i add various things there (small & big, vague and detailed)
-i add personal, leisure and work items (basicly everything i want/need to do)
Thanks
Reply by Gupta
Hello there!
Maybe i'm misusing AF, but I usually scan & cycle whole list through - i.e. i'm not focusing only on one page. So far this has also worked for me. Of course this might not work if i'd have tens of pages (currently i have four pages with 40lines each).
Reply by Mikko
Gupta:
I do same way - cycle whole list instead of one page.
Mark, any comments to this?
I do same way - cycle whole list instead of one page.
Mark, any comments to this?
Reply by Vp
One tip: I had one vague item "Project X", and it seemed that it didn't stand out for couple of days. Then i started to brainstorm & jot down something concrete on the same line like (after "project x") like:
-"Project X" - call Frans - check email xyz - remind Joan
And that helped!
Reply by Mark Forster
Gupta and Mikko:
You are basically just cycling through one open list. I've tried this in the past (in fact it was my first attempt at inventing a time management system about 15 years ago) and it is nothing like as effective as the AF system. I don't know how long you have been doing this, but my experience is that it works fine for about a week and then I give up in frustration because none of the more difficult stuff is getting done.
Have you tried doing AF the correct way?
You are basically just cycling through one open list. I've tried this in the past (in fact it was my first attempt at inventing a time management system about 15 years ago) and it is nothing like as effective as the AF system. I don't know how long you have been doing this, but my experience is that it works fine for about a week and then I give up in frustration because none of the more difficult stuff is getting done.
Have you tried doing AF the correct way?
Reply by Gupta
Hi Mark,
thanks for your explanation. Basicly you mean that one page is "closed list". And final page is open list.
Reply by Mark Forster
Gupta:
Each page is a closed list, except for the last one, which is open.
When you are using the list as one long list in the way you are doing, you are comparing each item with all the other items on the list. That means that there is a natural tendency to go for the easier or simpler items.
But with AF you only comparing each item with the other items on the same page. Your range of choice is much narrower. So for instance my first active page contains only two items "Sort CDs" and "Prepare Friday's seminar". This means I have the following choices: do both items; do one of the items and leave the other for the next visit to the page; or do neither of the items and dismiss both of them.
Each page is a closed list, except for the last one, which is open.
When you are using the list as one long list in the way you are doing, you are comparing each item with all the other items on the list. That means that there is a natural tendency to go for the easier or simpler items.
But with AF you only comparing each item with the other items on the same page. Your range of choice is much narrower. So for instance my first active page contains only two items "Sort CDs" and "Prepare Friday's seminar". This means I have the following choices: do both items; do one of the items and leave the other for the next visit to the page; or do neither of the items and dismiss both of them.
Reply by Kenny D.
I find myself not liking the idea of highlighting items to dismiss them and crossing off something that is partially complete (had some work done on it).
In the past, I have tended to cross items off my list when I completely cancel the item, never to work on it again. I place a checkmark next to items that are complete. I feel that highlighting an item would be a way to indicate that this item needs to be done next.
I also feel unsure about where to place some items that I feel I might want to do someday - books I want to read sometime maybe next month and also items that depend on previous items being done. Currently the only way I have found to resolve this is put the first item on the current page I have been adding items to, and then put the item that depends on that item being done on the next page by itself.
In the past, I have tended to cross items off my list when I completely cancel the item, never to work on it again. I place a checkmark next to items that are complete. I feel that highlighting an item would be a way to indicate that this item needs to be done next.
I also feel unsure about where to place some items that I feel I might want to do someday - books I want to read sometime maybe next month and also items that depend on previous items being done. Currently the only way I have found to resolve this is put the first item on the current page I have been adding items to, and then put the item that depends on that item being done on the next page by itself.
Reply by Kenny D.
Almost forgot: +1 vote on telling people to try it on paper & get that working before switching to a software solution.
Reply by Mike
Kenny,
If you put your "someday" items on your list they will eventually be dismissed. If you use a permanent book and keep the old pages, you'll have them there to review for later.
As to what highlighting means, it can mean anything you want it to mean. But I get your point, it does seem to imply emphasis rather than the opposite ... dismissal. I had no trouble switching over because I don't highlight until the page is "inactive" and so there is no confusion. I would not be on the pages seeing the highlighted items unless I was looking for dismissed (i.e. someday) items and then I WANT them emphasized to stand out from the completed ones. Just a thought.
If you put your "someday" items on your list they will eventually be dismissed. If you use a permanent book and keep the old pages, you'll have them there to review for later.
As to what highlighting means, it can mean anything you want it to mean. But I get your point, it does seem to imply emphasis rather than the opposite ... dismissal. I had no trouble switching over because I don't highlight until the page is "inactive" and so there is no confusion. I would not be on the pages seeing the highlighted items unless I was looking for dismissed (i.e. someday) items and then I WANT them emphasized to stand out from the completed ones. Just a thought.
Reply by Christine B
Kenny
Agree with Mike re the highlighting - if you only highlight at the point specified in the instructions then only non-active pages will have highlighted items on. If you highlight an item as "needing to be done next" you are effectively rationally grading the urgency of that item and not working with the item "that stands out". Additional highlighting or notation can affect the effectiveness of AF in that it disrupts the scanning of items.
Give it a try exactly as written for a while and then see if you feel differently.
Actually, with regard to someday items I think there can be value in adding them into your list. Not necessarily all of them, and not in one go, but if you add them in you may find that, rather than dismiss them you may take action on them and start to progress them. And if not, it's no big deal. They just stay on your lists as "dismissed" and will be reviewed under your periodic review of dismissed items, when they can be re-added if you wish.
Agree with Mike re the highlighting - if you only highlight at the point specified in the instructions then only non-active pages will have highlighted items on. If you highlight an item as "needing to be done next" you are effectively rationally grading the urgency of that item and not working with the item "that stands out". Additional highlighting or notation can affect the effectiveness of AF in that it disrupts the scanning of items.
Give it a try exactly as written for a while and then see if you feel differently.
Actually, with regard to someday items I think there can be value in adding them into your list. Not necessarily all of them, and not in one go, but if you add them in you may find that, rather than dismiss them you may take action on them and start to progress them. And if not, it's no big deal. They just stay on your lists as "dismissed" and will be reviewed under your periodic review of dismissed items, when they can be re-added if you wish.
Reply by Sam G
Mark,
It seems like what you're saying above (about your two items left on your first page) is that you can do an initial scan on a page, do the slower scan, choose one item, and then go on to the next page without dismissing that last item. I think I've seen you say this in another post, do at least one item on a page before going on to the next. In your original emailed instructions though, I thought you said keep rescanning one page until nothing stands out, and then dismiss everything left on the page before gong on to the next one. I've actually been doing the first, since I saw the post about do one before going on, but I want to check in about this. When to go on without dismissing and when to dismiss and then go on seems to be at the heart of this system, and I want to give it a try as intended. Feel free to point me to another post if there's one that is the latest iteration.
As for the mention of one list above, I actually am really liking having a work list and an everything else list. If there's a task that needs to be done during work hours (call bank about x) I put it on the work list, otherwise it's on the everything else list. This lets me compare only things I can be doing (a bit of the GTD context take on things). I also really don't like to be concerning myself with all I have to do at work when I'm at home, and vice versa. This was one of my peeves about GTD - one is supposed to process all things in order, and software is frequently set up that way. So I would end up processing tons of home stuff at work and work stuff at home. I love the clean break I have between the worlds - I have more peace of mind in each place about I'm focusing on.
Thanks,
Sam
It seems like what you're saying above (about your two items left on your first page) is that you can do an initial scan on a page, do the slower scan, choose one item, and then go on to the next page without dismissing that last item. I think I've seen you say this in another post, do at least one item on a page before going on to the next. In your original emailed instructions though, I thought you said keep rescanning one page until nothing stands out, and then dismiss everything left on the page before gong on to the next one. I've actually been doing the first, since I saw the post about do one before going on, but I want to check in about this. When to go on without dismissing and when to dismiss and then go on seems to be at the heart of this system, and I want to give it a try as intended. Feel free to point me to another post if there's one that is the latest iteration.
As for the mention of one list above, I actually am really liking having a work list and an everything else list. If there's a task that needs to be done during work hours (call bank about x) I put it on the work list, otherwise it's on the everything else list. This lets me compare only things I can be doing (a bit of the GTD context take on things). I also really don't like to be concerning myself with all I have to do at work when I'm at home, and vice versa. This was one of my peeves about GTD - one is supposed to process all things in order, and software is frequently set up that way. So I would end up processing tons of home stuff at work and work stuff at home. I love the clean break I have between the worlds - I have more peace of mind in each place about I'm focusing on.
Thanks,
Sam
Reply by Mark Forster
Sam:
What the instructions say is:
7. If you go to a page and no item stands out for you on your first pass through it, then all the outstanding items on that page are dismissed without re-entering them.
What the instructions say is:
7. If you go to a page and no item stands out for you on your first pass through it, then all the outstanding items on that page are dismissed without re-entering them.
Reply by Sam G
So in the case you describe here:
http://www.markforster.net/blog/2009/1/6/clarification-speed-of-movement.html
are you moving very rapidly from page 1 to 15 by doing one item on each page and dismissing the rest? Or are you doing one item and moving on to the next page without dismissing the items left on each page?
http://www.markforster.net/blog/2009/1/6/clarification-speed-of-movement.html
are you moving very rapidly from page 1 to 15 by doing one item on each page and dismissing the rest? Or are you doing one item and moving on to the next page without dismissing the items left on each page?
Reply by Sam G
OK, I just re-read your instructions and I think I can answer my own question. If you've done something on a page, and when going through that page again nothing stands out, you don't have to dismiss, since you already did something on that page. It's only if on your first pass on a page nothing stands out, then you dismiss things. You're probably sick of answering questions like these. It's so interesting to me - I've read these instructions at least a dozen times in the ten days I've had them, and that's the first time that part has been clear to me; the first time I saw it that way and got it.